Should I Rebuild my Automatic Pool cleaner or Get a New One?: Your Pool Cleaner Life Expectancy

If you own a Suction Side or Pressure Side Automatic Pool Cleaner, you be wondering if it is worth the expense to rebuild the cleaner or if you would be better off getting a new one once your cleaner wears down. Robotic Cleaners are a little different and I will touch on those later. But for the first two cleaner types you may be surprised how long you can keep them working in your pool.

Up until about 5 years ago, I had 2 pools that were running with a Polaris 180 Pressure Side Cleaner in them. Not a Polaris 280. The Polaris 180 was introduced over 40 plus years ago! The only reason they were replaced was that unlike the 280 where the Stem Pipe is a replaceable part, the Stem Pipe on the 180 was built into the cleaner body. So once the Stem Pipe broke on both cleaners it was not worth the cost to install a new body. I hope this gives you some idea of how long your cleaner can last in your pool just by rebuilding it when the parts wear out.

Manufacturers are also making things easier for the consumer to easily replace parts by creating drop-in rebuild kits. The Hayward PoolCleaner (Phoenix/AquaNaut) the Hayward Navigator/PoolVac, the Polaris 3900 Sport/P39 to name the rebuild kits I really appreciate. For example, if you have a Polaris 3900 Sport or P39 for about $160 you can purchase the rebuilt kit which includes all of the main internal parts and basically renew your cleaner. The retail price for a new Polaris 3900 Sport without a rebate is $899. Considerable savings and if you rebuild the cleaner every 5 years you can easily get 20 years out of it before the cost adds up to the price of a new cleaner. Pretty amazing!

Another thing to note about Pressure Side Booster Pump cleaners is that you are only running them for about 2 hours each day during the season (or all year if you don’t close your pool in the winter). This means that unlike a Suction Cleaner that is running 8-10 hours per day, the parts will last much longer. So Pressure Cleaners have a built-in longer life span, to begin with.

So how long can you keep a Suction Side Cleaner like a Hayward Navigator running? I recently filmed a rebuild video and the Navigator that I featured in that video was over 20 years old, maybe even older. You can pretty much rebuild the Hayward Navigator/PoolVac until the shell wears out. Same with the Zodiac MX8 and MX6. The only concern would be the hoses on a suction and pressure cleaner. They may wear out long before the cleaner. At some point, it may be logical to purchase a new cleaner since you do get all new hoses with it.
Robotic Pool Cleaners are a little different since you can’t do a lot of hands-on repairs. You can do simple things like changing the brushes or belts but many times it is safer to take it into a service center or ship it to the manufacturer for repairs. But like a Pressure Cleaner, the Robotic Cleaner has a built-in extended life span since you only typically run them once or twice a week for 2-3 hours at a time. If you replace the wear parts on a Robotic cleaner you can get a good 5-8 years of use out of it.

So when is it logical to replace your old cleaner vs rebuilding it again for the 3rd time? I would say that the hoses are an important factor. If those are pretty worn out a new cleaner may be a smart move. Also, if you don’t like how your cleaner is working in your pool you may want to purchase a new and different cleaner. And last, if the body is looking like a relic from the Titanic, there are some aesthetic factors to consider. If your wife is complaining about the ugly pool cleaner maybe it is time for a new one.

Visit my Website:
YouTube Video Index: – A list of all of my videos.
Join me on Patreon:
Podcast Website:
Coaching Site:
Shop at Leslie’s: Leslie’s Pool Supplies has been do-it-yourselfers and pool trade professionals trusted partner since 1963, providing quality products and services to make pool care easy and solutions and expertise to do it right.

5 Tips for Effectively Maintaining a Swimming Pool

Swimming pools are a source of exercise, relaxation and enjoyment. If you have a pool in your house, here are 5 tips to maintain it effectively.

Pool Remodeling Ideas

This article discusses three pool remodeling ideas, such as adding an infinity edge, adding waterfall features, and selecting the right shape for your pool. Each of these ideas can change or enhance the look of your backyard.

Learn More About Inground Pool Prices, So You Can Buy the Right Pool for You

For most companies, inground pool prices are fairly standard – but only if you get the standard pool. When you want a custom inground pool, prices can rise based on the materials used, the size, and the filtration system you choose. That’s why it’s so important to do your research; otherwise, you could get stuck with hidden costs that you weren’t anticipating.

Pool Services Season Is Actually All Year Long

Summer is not the only season you should be maintaining your pool. Without proper maintenance, pools can develop serious problems that could have been prevented if they received proper maintenance at first. An experienced pool service is the safest bet to ensure your pool is always suitable for swimming.

Saltwater Vs Regular Chlorine Pools

This article explains the differences between having a chlorine pool and a saltwater pool. Chlorine is great for killing bacteria, but saltwater is not as harsh on people’s skin and clothing.

You May Also Like